January 26, 2008

Making Memories Circle Cutter

Thanks for visiting Craft Critique! If you've come here from a search engine or from a direct link, you might be missing out on more content! Please visit CraftCritique.com. And for more amazing content such as projects, artist interviews and more, sign up for our Monthly Newsletter.
Reported by Martha Bonneau

I recently had a project come up where I was going to need to make lots and lots of circles in various sizes...I realized quite quickly that I was going to need to break down and buy yet another tool for my scrap-room as making precise circles without the appropriate tool could prove to be quite difficult. I went to a couple of stores and looked at all of my options and finally came home with a Making Memories Circle Cutter.












A couple of things that drew me to it vs. some of my other choices were the fact that it would cut up to a 9" circle, larger than that of the EK Success Curvy Cutter or the Fiskars Circle Cutter, I also liked the fact that it was pretty compact and would not take up a lot of space in my work area. It is a relatively simple tool to use. There is a blade in a small holder on the arm that can be adjusted for either right or left handed users. This same holder can be adjusted with a couple of turns of a knob to determine how large of a circle you want to cut. You simply place your paper on a cutting mat (one is provided with the tool), center the tool on the paper, press down on the center of the tool and then turn the arm in a complete circle to make the cut. Sounds easy enough, but MM stresses both on the packaging and on their website that it will take practice. I found that you really need to apply a lot of pressure (which means you will be standing while using it) and have the steady hand of a surgeon to get multiple perfect circles, I frequently ended up with a not so perfect circle because I moved just a little or hesitated while cutting and the circle did not line up exactly when I got to the end. Another thing I found frustrating was when I tried to cut a circle within a circle, I found it next to impossible to get the interior circle centered.

All in all this is a handy little tool. I like that it cuts so many different sizes of circles, it is easy to see where you are cutting, replacement blades are housed in the handle of the tool so there is no fumbling around looking for a new blade when you are in the middle of a project, plus the fact that it comes with it's own cuting mat makes it something I would pack to take to a crop with me. Just do as MM says...practice, practice, practice! MSRP is $19.99, I found it for a little less and was able to use a coupon.

4 Comments:

Dee said...

I also have this cutter. I had the same issues you did with not getting perfect circles. I agree you have to use this standing up and it does take a ton of practice. I use mine often and sorta have the hang of it. I must admit I still don't use it on my favorite designer paper, fearful I might not get a perfect circle that time:)
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this cutter.
Dee

The Lowry Family said...

I am completely NOT a fan of this product. I feel if a first time scrapbooker were to try this they would get frustrated and never cut a circle again....I am still on the hunt for a favorite circle cutter....

Anonymous said...

I was surprised that the package does not come with very good instructions. I had to learn online how to assemble the cutter. Not too much to putting it together but you have to know how to insert the blade, and what to do with the stickie circle that comes in the package. I still don't know why I had to insert 2 blades. My first 2 tries came out perfect. So far so good.

Anonymous said...

Not a fan of this cutter. As I am new to scrapbooking, I did not want to spend a lot on a product I might not use very often. At 19.99 minus 40% discount, the price was reasonable. Poor instructions, none on how to put it together, had to find that on-line. Have to press very hard and it still won't cut anything heavier than paper. Very difficult to continue to hold down & press all the way around without stopping or letting up. Should not be this hard to get a perfect circle.....